House Speaker Puan Maharani Defends TNI Law Revision Despite Public Outcry

Jakarta. House Speaker Puan Maharani defended the revision of the Indonesian Military (TNI) Law, asserting that the amendments have followed proper legislative mechanisms and do not reintroduce the controversial dual-function role of the military.
Speaking at the parliamentary complex in Senayan on Monday, Puan said the revision of Law No. 34/2004 on the TNI had undergone extensive discussions with various stakeholders. “A press conference has already clarified that three articles have been amended with input from multiple parties. There are no violations or actions that undermine democracy,” she said.
Puan outlined three main changes in the revised law. The first is an amendment to Article 3, which defines the military’s position under the president’s command in military deployment and operations, while its defense policy and administrative support fall under the Defense Ministry. The second is Article 53, which extends the retirement age for TNI personnel from 55 to 62 years. The third is an expansion of opportunities for active military personnel to hold positions in government ministries and agencies, as stipulated in Article 47.
“These amendments do not discuss or reinstate the dual-function role of the military,” Puan reiterated.
Her remarks came in response to initial opposition from her mother, Megawati Soekarnoputri, the chairwoman of the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI-P). According to Puan, Megawati’s concerns were raised before deliberations began. “That was before we discussed it together and reached a conclusion,” she said.
The PDI-P, now leading the working committee for the law’s revision, has since endorsed the changes. Deputy House Speaker Sufmi Dasco Ahmad also dismissed concerns about civilian supremacy being undermined. “The draft circulating on social media differs from what is being officially discussed between the DPR and the government,” he stated in a press conference.
Dasco confirmed that the revisions allow more active military officers to serve in civilian roles, including in the Attorney General’s Office, where military officers can now be appointed as Military Criminal Prosecutors under the Attorney General’s authority. “Previously, only 10 ministries and agencies could appoint active TNI personnel. Now, there are additional institutions based on necessity,” he added.
Controversy Over Closed-Door Deliberations
Public concerns have intensified after reports emerged that discussions on the amendments were held behind closed doors at the Fairmont Hotel in Jakarta. Critics argue that such secrecy contradicts the government’s calls for austerity and transparency, especially as President Prabowo Subianto has urged cost-cutting measures across government institutions.
The proposal to increase the number of civilian posts available to active military personnel—from 10 to 15, including in the Coordinating Ministry for Political, Legal, and Security Affairs, the Attorney General’s Office, and the Supreme Court—has sparked opposition from civil society groups. The Civil Society Coalition for Security Sector Reform warned that this change could blur the lines between military and civilian governance.
“This risks undermining civilian supremacy and increasing military dominance in bureaucracy,” the coalition said in a statement.
On Friday, three activists stormed into the hotel meeting room in an attempt to disrupt discussions, highlighting growing discontent over the proposed revisions. Despite the backlash, lawmakers aim to finalize the amendments before the legislative recess on March 21.
Tags: Keywords:Related Articles
Military Blames OPM-Affiliated Group for Attack on Teachers in Papua
The group that allegedly carried out the attack in Anggruk district was led by local separatist leader Elius Kogap, a spokesman said.Protesters Burn Security Posts at Malang Legislature During Anti-Military Law Rally
By 6 p.m., the demonstration escalated as protesters vandalized property inside the legislative compound, including security cameras.Public May Challenge Revised TNI Law, Says Minister
The public can seek a judicial review of the revised TNI Law, Minister Supratman said, addressing concerns over military-civilian roles.Puan Brushes Off Jokowi-PDIP Rift, Calls Ties 'Always Warm'
Puan Maharani denies tensions between PDIP and Jokowi, calling their ties "always warm" despite his ouster and political rift in 2024.DPR Urges Dialogue as Students Protest TNI Law
Hundreds of students staged a protest at Pancasila Gate on Thursday, opposing the newly passed Indonesian Military (TNI) Law.The TNI Draft Law Enacted into Law, Here Are 4 Key Articles That Were Amended
The People's Representative Council (DPR) has finally passed the Draft Law on the Indonesian National Armed Forces (TNI)DPR Approves Military Law Revisions, Expanding Active-Duty Roles in Civilian Posts
The DPR passed the revised TNI law, expanding active-duty roles in civilian posts and raising retirement age, sparking debate.Students Force Justice Minister Out of His Car amid Protests against Military Law Revisions
Despite efforts from Supratman’s aides to defuse the situation, the students remained resolute, preventing the car from moving.House Speaker Puan Maharani Defends TNI Law Revision Despite Public Outcry
Puan Maharani defends TNI law revision, rejecting concerns over military’s expanded role and closed-door deliberations amid public objectionLuxury Hotel Venue Adds Controversy to Military Law Discussions
"We must ensure that all participants get adequate rest in between marathon sessions," House Secretary-General Indra Iskandar said.The Latest
No US Orders for West Java Ceramics Makers as Trade Policies Bite
As of April this year, only two containers of potteries had been shipped to Europe, with no deliveries recorded to the US.Conclave Politics Begin but Many Cardinals Barely Know Each Other
All that is certain about the upcoming conclave is that there is no certainty.What to Know About the Funeral and Burial of Pope Francis
ope Francis, the first Latin American pope, will be buried at St. Mary Major after a Vatican funeral, marking the end of his 12-year papacy.Norwegian Man Found Dead in River in West Sumatra
A 71-year-old Norwegian man was found dead in a West Sumatra river after reportedly falling from a bridge while cycling.W. Java Governor Proposes China-Inspired Military Rehab for Depok Teens
Dedi Mulyadi proposes military-style rehab for troubled Depok teens, citing rising student brawls and parental frustration.Most Popular
