If Saka Tatal Wins Last Appeal, Entire Convicts in Vina Murder Case Will Be Acquitted

Thomas Rizal
July 25, 2024 | 11:04 am
SHARE
Saka Tatal arrives at the Cirebon District Court, West Java, Wednesday, July 24, 2024,  to attend a review of his murder conviction. He has served four years in prison for allegedly murdering teenagers Vina Dewi Arsita and Muhammad Rizky Rudiana in 2016. (Antara Photo/Dedhez Anggara)
Saka Tatal arrives at the Cirebon District Court, West Java, Wednesday, July 24, 2024, to attend a review of his murder conviction. He has served four years in prison for allegedly murdering teenagers Vina Dewi Arsita and Muhammad Rizky Rudiana in 2016. (Antara Photo/Dedhez Anggara)

Jakarta. The ongoing review of the guilty verdict of Saka Tatal, one of the convicts in the 2016 deaths of Vina Dewi Arsita and her boyfriend, could affect the legal status of seven co-convicts in the case, a retired high-ranking police officer said in a recent interview.

Saka requested the review, the last legal avenue to overturn a conviction in Indonesia’s justice system, arguing that he was tortured and forced to confess to the murders by police and falsely convicted by the court in 2016.

He was sentenced to eight years in prison for the murders but was released four years ago for good behavior. However, seven co-convicts received life imprisonment, which offers no sentence cuts.

"If his judicial review is accepted, seven other convicts will most likely request the same, and the result will be identical,” Insp. General (ret.) Aryanto Sutadi said in an interview with BTV aired on Thursday.

Advertisement

Aryanto, who currently serves as an advisor to the national police chief, argued that the eight convicts were tried collectively under the same indictments. If the Supreme Court accepts the appeal of one defendant, it must treat his co-defendants equally.

New evidence and a recent decision by a key witness in the murder case to retract his testimonies could prove vital in the judicial review proceedings, he added.

Prosecution witness Dede Riswanto, who told police in 2016 that he saw the convicts chasing Vina and her boyfriend on motorcycles while carrying stones and bamboo sticks on the night just before their deaths, recently said he had lied to investigators on the order of the male victim’s father, Rudiana, who is a policeman.

"The latest evidence and testimonies indicate that they weren’t involved in the murders and rape. This case seems to be a fatal traffic accident but was fabricated into a murder and rape case," Aryanto said.

Police accused the eight convicts of murdering the couple and gang-raping Vina in Cirebon, West Java, on August 27, 2016.

Saka, despite being officially declared a free man on Wednesday after receiving sentence cuts, filed a judicial review to clear his name and restore his reputation.

The seven convicts serving life imprisonment include Jaya, 23; Supriyanto, 20; Eka Sandi, 24; Hadi Saputra, 23; Eko Ramadani, 27; Sudirman, 21; and Rivaldi Aditya Wardana, 21.

Tags: Keywords:
SHARE

The Latest


News 42 minutes ago

Indonesian Air Force Prepares Military Aircraft for Evacuation of Citizens from Iran and Israel

Data from Indonesia’s Foreign Affairs Ministry shows that 578 Indonesian nationals are in conflict zones -- 386 in Iran and 192 in Israel.
News 1 hours ago

Trump Says He'll Decide Whether US Will Directly Attack Iran within 2 Weeks

Israel's defense minister threatened Ayatollah Ali Khamenei after Iranian missiles crashed into a major hospital in southern Israel.
Business 3 hours ago

Danantara, Russia's RDIF to Launch $2.3 Billion Investment Platform

Russian Direct Investment Fund (RDIF) officially joins the list of Danantara's foreign partners.
News 4 hours ago

Iraq Looms Large: A Formidable Test Awaits Indonesia in World Cup Qualifier

Indonesia and Iraq have met 13 times, with Garuda emerging victorious only twice -- their last win coming in a friendly match back in 2000.
News 11 hours ago

Iranian Missile Strikes Show Israel's Aerial Defense Array Is Not Ironclad

Too many projectiles launched at once can overwhelm the system, which relies on technology and human decision-making to be effective.
COPYRIGHT © 2025 JAKARTA GLOBE. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED