Luxury Hotel Venue Adds Controversy to Military Law Discussions

Yustinus Paat
March 16, 2025 | 10:55 pm
SHARE
FILE - Armed Forces Commander General Agus Subiyanto, center, Army Chief of Staff General Maruli Simanjuntak, right, and Inspector General Muhammad Saleh Mustafa attend a hearing with the House of Representatives' Defense Commission at the national legislature building in Jakarta, Thursday, March 13, 2025. (Antara Photo/Asprilla Dwi Adha)
FILE - Armed Forces Commander General Agus Subiyanto, center, Army Chief of Staff General Maruli Simanjuntak, right, and Inspector General Muhammad Saleh Mustafa attend a hearing with the House of Representatives' Defense Commission at the national legislature building in Jakarta, Thursday, March 13, 2025. (Antara Photo/Asprilla Dwi Adha)

Jakarta. The decision to hold closed-door discussions on amendments to the military law at a luxury hotel in Jakarta has further fueled controversy amid public concerns about expanding military influence over civilian positions.

President Prabowo Subianto’s administration has proposed revisions to the existing military law, aiming to increase the number of civilian roles accessible to active military officers. The ongoing discussions at the Fairmont Hotel have fueled criticism, particularly amid Prabowo’s calls for austerity, which ban non-essential government trips, events, and ceremonies to cut state spending.

On Friday, three activists stormed into the hotel meeting room, attempting to disrupt the discussions.

“Please stop this meeting because it is being held behind closed doors,” Andri Yunus, one of the activists, shouted as he entered, catching attendees by surprise.

Advertisement

Despite criticism over the choice of a high-end hotel, lawmakers and the House of Representatives' secretariat defended the decision, arguing that the venue provides flexibility and proper rest for participants engaged in marathon discussions that began on Thursday.

Utut Adianto, a lawmaker from the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI-P), dismissed accusations that the meeting was an unnecessary burden on taxpayers, pointing out that past legislative discussions were also held at hotels.

"That’s your opinion. But if you check, it’s not unusual to hold meetings at hotels. The law on prosecutors’ offices was discussed at the Sheraton Hotel, and the personal data protection law was debated at the Intercontinental Hotel. Why didn’t you criticize those meetings at the time?" Utut told reporters at the venue.

However, both meetings he referenced took place before Prabowo’s administration implemented strict cost-cutting measures.

Luxury Hotel Venue Adds Controversy to Military Law Discussions
Representative Utut Adianto (PDI-P) speaks with reporters at the legislature compound in Jakarta, Thursday, March 13, 2025. (B-Universe Photo/Yustinus Paat)

Utut argued that the military law amendment requires intense and lengthy deliberations, and participants need to remain focused and sharp until discussions are concluded.

Separately, House Secretary-General Indra Iskandar defended the decision, saying that holding discussions at a hotel does not violate any regulations. Despite a 50 percent budget cut for the House secretariat, funds remain available for meetings on crucial legislative matters, such as the military law revision, he said.

"These discussions often last until the early hours and resume in the morning. We must ensure that all participants get adequate rest in between marathon sessions," Indra added, emphasizing that the Fairmont Hotel offered a government-approved rate within budgetary limits.

The proposed amendments seek to:

  • Expand the number of civilian roles available to active-duty military officers from 10 to 15 state agencies.
  • Extend the retirement age of military officers from 58 to 60.
  • Shift the command structure of the Armed Forces from the Defense Ministry to the Presidential Office.

Democracy activists have raised serious concerns, warning that these changes could undermine civilian supremacy and potentially pave the way for military rule, reminiscent of the three-decade authoritarian regime of former President Soeharto.

Tags: Keywords:
SHARE

Related Articles


News Mar 23, 2025 | 11:15 pm

Military Blames OPM-Affiliated Group for Attack on Teachers in Papua

The group that allegedly carried out the attack in Anggruk district was led by local separatist leader Elius Kogap, a spokesman said.
News Mar 23, 2025 | 11:13 pm

Protesters Burn Security Posts at Malang Legislature During Anti-Military Law Rally

By 6 p.m., the demonstration escalated as protesters vandalized property inside the legislative compound, including security cameras.
News Mar 22, 2025 | 11:12 am

Public May Challenge Revised TNI Law, Says Minister

The public can seek a judicial review of the revised TNI Law, Minister Supratman said, addressing concerns over military-civilian roles.
News Mar 20, 2025 | 11:03 am

DPR Approves Military Law Revisions, Expanding Active-Duty Roles in Civilian Posts

The DPR passed the revised TNI law, expanding active-duty roles in civilian posts and raising retirement age, sparking debate.
News Mar 19, 2025 | 10:37 pm

Students Force Justice Minister Out of His Car amid Protests against Military Law Revisions

Despite efforts from Supratman’s aides to defuse the situation, the students remained resolute, preventing the car from moving.
News Mar 17, 2025 | 7:00 pm

House Speaker Puan Maharani Defends TNI Law Revision Despite Public Outcry

Puan Maharani defends TNI law revision, rejecting concerns over military’s expanded role and closed-door deliberations amid public objection
News Mar 16, 2025 | 10:55 pm

Luxury Hotel Venue Adds Controversy to Military Law Discussions

"We must ensure that all participants get adequate rest in between marathon sessions," House Secretary-General Indra Iskandar said.
News Mar 15, 2025 | 10:32 pm

Protesters Storm Hotel Meeting on Military Law Amendment

They carried a banner that reads: "What about switching places? Military officers serve as civil servants, and civilians carry the arms?"
News Mar 14, 2025 | 2:51 am

Two Members of Prabowo’s Cabinet to Resign from Military Amid Public Debate

Meanwhile, Lieutenant Colonel Teddy Indra Wijaya, who serves as cabinet secretary, is not required to leave the military.
News Mar 13, 2025 | 3:14 pm

Breaking Down the TNI Law Revision: Key Changes and Controversies

Indonesia’s military law revision sparks concerns over civilian supremacy as lawmakers push changes before the upcoming recess.

The Latest


Business 3 hours ago

No US Orders for West Java Ceramics Makers as Trade Policies Bite

As of April this year, only two containers of potteries had been shipped to Europe, with no deliveries recorded to the US.
News 5 hours ago

Conclave Politics Begin but Many Cardinals Barely Know Each Other

All that is certain about the upcoming conclave is that there is no certainty.
News Apr 26, 2025 | 2:18 pm

What to Know About the Funeral and Burial of Pope Francis

ope Francis, the first Latin American pope, will be buried at St. Mary Major after a Vatican funeral, marking the end of his 12-year papacy.
News Apr 26, 2025 | 12:51 pm

Norwegian Man Found Dead in River in West Sumatra

A 71-year-old Norwegian man was found dead in a West Sumatra river after reportedly falling from a bridge while cycling.
Lifestyle Apr 26, 2025 | 12:30 pm

W. Java Governor Proposes China-Inspired Military Rehab for Depok Teens

Dedi Mulyadi proposes military-style rehab for troubled Depok teens, citing rising student brawls and parental frustration.
COPYRIGHT © 2025 JAKARTA GLOBE. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED