Shin Tae-yong Criticized for Selecting "Too Many" Naturalized Players for Argentina Match

Jakarta. Indonesia's head coach Shin Tae-yong was criticized for selecting eight naturalized citizens in the national squad for a friendly match against Argentina on June 19.
Ignatius Indro, the chairman of the national team supporters' association, said the upcoming friendly provides a rare opportunity for Indonesian players to get the experience of playing against the world champion.
"But the opportunity for the local players to play against world-class opponents like Lionel Messi has been reduced by naturalized players," Indro said in Jakarta on Tuesday.
Shin has announced his selection for the friendly against Argentina. Of 26 players, eight are naturalized Indonesian citizens including Marc Klok, Stefano Lilipaly, Jordi Amat, Elkan Baggott, Sandy Walsh, Rafael Struick, Shayne Pattynama, and Ivar Jenner.
Indro said half of the naturalized players deserve the selection because they have been with the national team for years. They include Klok, Lilipaly, Bagot, and Amat.
"But the other four only reduce the chance of local players to demonstrate their skill in front of Argentina's top players," he said.
"We regret that STY fields too many naturalized players," Indro said, mentioning the coach by initials.
Indro pointed to the recent success of the U-22 team under Manager Indra Sjafri who fielded entirely local players to win the SEA Games gold medal.
"Coach Indra Sjafri has proved that our local players can match the quality of naturalized players by winning the SEA Games," Indro said.
Tags: Keywords:Related Articles
Indonesia Routed 6-0 by Japan but Still March On
Coach Patrick Kluivert’s experimental lineup failed to withstand Japan’s high tempo and tactical precision.Indonesia Nears FIFA Top 100 After Defeating China in World Cup Qualifier
The projected jump of seven places would place the Garuda squad at its highest position in recent years.Indonesia Edges China 1–0 to Keep 2026 World Cup Dream Alive
The victory pushes Indonesia to third place in the group with 12 points, trailing behind group leaders Japan and Australia.‘This Isn’t Europe’: Prabowo Joins PSSI Honorary Council
The move contrasts with the European model of insulating football federations from government influence.PSSI Chief Warns Against Nepotism in National Football Talent Scouting
PSSI chief Erick Thohir vows to purge nepotism in scouting as Indonesia prepares to host 2026 AFC U-23 Asian Cup qualifiers.How to Get Tickets for Indonesia vs China: Garuda ID Now Mandatory
Watch Indonesia take on China in a key World Cup qualifier on June 5. Tickets now on sale; Garuda ID required for entry.Australian Health Tech BrainEye Sets Sights on Indonesian Sports Industry, PSSI Deal
BrainEye lets footballers screen for concussions using an AI-driven eye-tracking technology.Japan Becomes 1st Team to Qualify for World Cup As Kluivert’s Indonesian Debut Doesn’t Go Well
At its eighth straight World Cup, Japan joins co-hosts the United States, Canada, and Mexico in the expanded 48-team tournament.PSSI Introduces Jordi Cruyff as Indonesia’s New Technical Advisor
Jordi Cruyff joins Indonesia as technical advisor, focusing on strategy, talent development, and the team’s 2026 World Cup qualification.Jordi Cruyff Arrives in Indonesia to Begin Role as National Team Technical Advisor
Indonesia aims to incorporate elements of European football into the team’s playstyle -- particularly the famous Total Football system.The Latest
Iranian Missile Strikes Show Israel's Aerial Defense Array Is Not Ironclad
Too many projectiles launched at once can overwhelm the system, which relies on technology and human decision-making to be effective.Russia Ready to Boost Oil Supplies to Indonesia, Putin Tells Prabowo
Putin tells Prabowo that Russia is ready to ramp up oil and LNG supplies to Indonesia.Indonesia’s Bumi Resources to Acquire Australian Gold and Copper Miner Wolfram Limited
The acquisition is Bumi's strategic move to expand into critical minerals amid growing global demand for green energy transition metals.Morowali Industrial Park Pledges Reforms After Environmental Warning from Minister
Despite the setback, Dedy stressed that IMIP uses advanced technology to reduce emissions from its nickel smelters.Russia's Economy Minister Says the Country Is on 'The Brink of Recession'
High defense spending has propelled growth and kept unemployment low in Russia despite fueling inflation.Most Popular
