Google Faces New Antitrust Trial Over Ad Tech Monopoly

Associated Press
September 9, 2024 | 10:36 pm
SHARE
File - The San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge is seen behind a Google sign at the company s office in San Francisco on April 12, 2023. (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu, File)
File - The San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge is seen behind a Google sign at the company s office in San Francisco on April 12, 2023. (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu, File)

Virginia. Google is confronting a new antitrust trial, a month after a judge deemed its search engine a monopoly. This latest case focuses on Google's dominance in online advertising technology, with the Justice Department and several states arguing that the tech giant has monopolized the market for matching publishers with advertisers.

The government's case centers on Google's control over both the buy and sell sides of online advertising, which allegedly allows it to retain up to 36 cents of every dollar in transactions. The prosecution argues that Google's monopoly extends to ad exchanges, which facilitate transactions between buyers and sellers.

Justice Department lawyer Julia Tarver Wood emphasized the severity of the situation, stating, “One monopoly is bad enough. But a trifecta of monopolies is what we have here.”

Google counters that the government's perspective is outdated, reflecting a time when desktop computers were the primary means of internet access. Google's lawyer, Karen Dunn, dismissed the case as a relic, likening it to "a time capsule with a Blackberry, an iPod, and a Blockbuster video card."

Advertisement

Dunn also cautioned that any action against Google could unintentionally benefit other tech giants like Amazon, Microsoft, and TikTok, rather than aiding small businesses. She pointed out that Google's ad revenue has been stable, with only a slight decline from $31.7 billion in 2021 to $31.3 billion in 2023.

The trial, which started Monday, will be decided by U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema, known for her work on high-profile terrorism cases and patent disputes. Originally set as a jury trial, it was converted to a bench trial after Google paid over $2 million to remove the jury requirement.

The Virginia trial follows a significant defeat for Google in Washington, D.C., where a judge declared its search engine a monopoly. Additionally, a December ruling labeled Google's Android app store a monopoly.

In the D.C. case, the judge has yet to decide on remedies. The proposed sanctions could potentially restrict Google's exclusivity agreements, which ensure its search engine remains the default choice for many users.

Peter Cohan, a Babson College professor, suggested that the Virginia trial could have more severe consequences for Google. "Divestitures are definitely a possible remedy for this second case," Cohan said. "It could be potentially more significant than initially meets the eye."

The government's witnesses are expected to include executives from major newspaper publishers like The New York Times and Gannett. They argue that Google's fees have harmed publishers by reducing their ad revenue and forcing them to increase ads or place more content behind paywalls.

Gannett executive Tim Wolfe testified that the company feels compelled to use Google's ad tech despite high fees, as it cannot afford to lose access to Google's large advertiser base.

Google disputes claims of excessive fees, arguing that its integrated ad technology improves performance and security. The company also highlights that customers have alternatives to its ad services.

The trial, set to last several weeks, is being held in a courthouse with strict rules, including a ban on cellphones, which limits real-time reporting from the tech press.

Tags: Keywords:
SHARE

Related Articles


Tech Apr 15, 2025 | 10:13 pm

Japan's Anti-Monopoly Watchdog Accuses Google of Violations in Smartphones

Japanese regulators order Google to stop the pre-installation of the Google search engine in Android smartphones.
Tech Mar 19, 2025 | 3:49 pm

Google to Buy Cybersecurity Firm Wiz for $32 Billion, Its Biggest Deal Ever

Google has agreed to acquire cybersecurity firm Wiz for $32 billion, marking the tech giant’s largest-ever acquisition
Business Mar 14, 2025 | 9:18 pm

Indonesia Collects $1.6B in VAT from Digital Giants, Crypto Adds $74M

Indonesia collects $1.6B in digital taxes from Amazon, Google, Meta, and More. Crypto contributes Rp 1.21 trillion.
Tech Jan 22, 2025 | 3:02 pm

Indonesian Antitrust Watchdog Hits Google with $13.1 Million Fine

Indonesia’s antitrust watchdog KPPU has fined Google $13.1 million for monopolistic practices in its Play Store.
News Dec 12, 2024 | 2:39 pm

Australia Plans to Tax Digital Platforms That Don’t Pay for News

Meta says the proposal overlooks that users don’t visit its platforms for news and publishers post content for the value they get.
Tech Nov 25, 2024 | 8:42 pm

Judge to Hear Arguments on Whether Google's Ad Tech Constitutes a Monopoly

The Justice Department alleges Google's advertising technology amounts to an illegal monopoly
Business Nov 14, 2024 | 9:50 am

Indonesia’s Digital Economy On Track to Reach $90 Billion in 2024, Led by E-Commerce

Indonesia’s digital economy is set to hit $90B (Rp 1,422T) in GMV this year, up 13% from last year, per a report by Google Indonesia

The Latest


News 6 hours ago

End of the Road: Supreme Court Seals 15-Year Sentence for Johnny Plate

The ruling marks the end of Johnny’s legal battle, confirming that he has exhausted all possible avenues for appeal.
Business 7 hours ago

Indonesia’s Rice Reserves Set to Hit Record 4 Million Tons

The previous record for rice reserves was set in September 1985 at 3 million tons, achieved over nine months.
Business 10 hours ago

China Seeks United Front With Latin America in Countering Trump's Trade War

China has become a reliable trade and development partner for many, in contrast to the uncertainty and instability of Trump’s America.
News 10 hours ago

Colonel Among 13 Dead in Accidental Explosion During Army Operation

Colonel Antonius Hermawan was the highest-ranking officer killed in the incident, which also claimed the lives of nine civilians.
News 10 hours ago

Main Road Connecting Samarinda and Balikpapan Collapses After Heavy Flooding

The road was unable to withstand the strong floodwaters that had struck Samarinda since Monday.
COPYRIGHT © 2025 JAKARTA GLOBE. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED